This study provides an in depth
comparative analysis among Greek Commercial Bank institutions listed in Athens
Stock Exchange Market, during time period from 2006 to 2012. The analysis is
based on CAMEL methodology. The period 2007 to 2009 is characterized by high profitability,
liquidity and high capital adequacy. However, the eruption of the economic
crisis in Greece during 2009 and its ominous impacts is revealed on the bank
financial statements and reports. The results derived from the CAMELS evaluation have
been cross-tested using the Fixed Effects Model in a panel data analysis, which
verify that before crisis the traditional ratios of are statistically
significant, while the Sensitivity and Liquidity variables appeared to be the only rating components that provide insights into the banks financial situation
during the crisis period. We conclude that changes in the economic environment and the emergence of new risks
should be considered from both, bank managers and regulators, by the implementation
and evaluation of Banks’ rating system.